Shelley exchanged emails with Jeevacation on April 5, 2010, regarding flight times [1] [2]. Shelley's email address was [email protected] [2]. On December 7, 2010, Sarah K discussed Shelley needing to pick up some things, which were possibly located in a locked closet [3]. Shelley had dinner with Sue and someone else on August 2, 2011 [4] [5]. Shelley sent a birthday message to Jeffrey Epstein on January 20, 2014 [6]. Shelley used an iPhone to send messages [1] [6].