Eva Dubin had house seats for the play OSLO at the Vivian Beaumont Theater on June 20, 2017, with a total cost of $588.00 for 4 tickets [1] [2]. Eva Dubin was in contact with Karyna Shuliak regarding appointments with Dr. Kolker and Dr. Fassano in February and March 2015 [3] [6]. Eva Dubin also communicated with Karyna Shuliak in October 2015 to meet at 2:30 PM instead of 2:00 PM [4]. In 2019, Eva Dubin's email address changed, which she notified others about in an email [5]. Eva Dubin provided information to Karyna Shuliak about pre-surgery appointments and medication restrictions in January 2015 [6]. Eva Dubin was also sent muffins to her apartment in February 2019 [5].